Smackdown Semi-Final -Is There a Dog in This Book? VS Nerdy Birdy

Is There a Dog in This Book? VS Nerdy Birdy

Smackdown Semi-Final

Opinion

The winner with a vote of 8/13 is Is There a Dog In This Book?  The setting is interesting because it takes place in different rooms of the house. We chose this book because the characters were funny and we liked when the cats ran away from the dog.  The smaller cat encouraged bravery and helped the other cats not be afraid of the dog, which is something people should also do.  There was a great lesson about friendship in this book, that we could also learn.  This book was great because we had many wonders and it made us think.  The illustrator, included secret pictures on the back and front covers, this was a great surprise.  Is There a Dog In This Book, had lots of suspense, especially when the cats were hiding.  We like how the cats feelings about the dog changed from fear to worry.  Often in real life, dogs chase cats but in this book Viviane Schwarz had the animals be friends.  The illustrations were interesting because the animals were different shapes and sizes. A really interesting feature is that there were pop-ups all over with pictures and words. You would like this book if you like animals as main character instead of humans.