Friday, 27 January 2017

CLOTH LULLABY V.S HOUSE HELD BY TREES

Mini Mighty Smackdown Mme Smith's class

Cloth Lullaby V.S House HELD BY TREES              
                                                                                                                                            
CLOTH LULLABY SUMMARY:
by Amy Novesky
illustrated by Isabelle Arsenault 

There was a girl named Louise  she lived in a big house that was built on a river. Louise was raised by a river. Her mother repairs fabric in the family's workshop. Her  dad always has to leave every single time. Louise was furious so she threw herself in the river. But Louise's father travels so he couldn't do anything about it. But when she followed the river it leaded to Paris. She made sculptures of spiders and called it mama.
  
                                                       
HOUSE HELD BY TREES  SUMMARY:      
by Ted kooser      illustrated by Jon klassen
There there was a girl and a boy that lived with there father. In an lonely field. When the children grew up they remembered the past 
when they played in the woods. When the children returned
to there house they missed it. So they moved in but the roots 
were growing and the hose came to a chaos. 


CLOTH LULLABY won the Smackdown vote by 3/3 
Opinion:
We chose Cloth lullaby because of how Amy Novesky put the action so emotional and how thoughtful we should be to our self
And that the pictures represent the writing piece. She  shows motion and body language. The illustrator Isabelle Arsenal 
gives good details and gives clues even before you read the
book.  


Image result for cloth lullaby  Image result for house held up by trees


















No comments:

Post a Comment