Grumpy pants by Clare Messer vs. A child of books  by Oliver Sam and Jeffers Winston
Tribe pickle pies: Harpreet , Madison,  Mantra,  

And the winner is.................
Grumpy pants by Clare Messer

(Mrs.Holden and grade four mini mighty Smack down)

Winner: The book Grumpy pants was the winner. It was actually unanimous (everyone voted for the same book). We gave it a rating of 10/10. We loved this book because it was very funny. The illustrations and the writing just matched and were a perfect fit.


Summary: The book Grumpy pants was very funny and we loved how he was very VERY grumpy.
We love how the illustrator shows the penguin's emotions and especially how he shows his anger. It's awesome how the words and the pictures match and help tell the story! This book is the winner we voted 10/10. A child of books was a very interesting book because many of the pictures were actually made of words. We liked this book because it was about adventures. It was a cool and groovy and was definitively not what we expected!