SHY vs Finding Winnie

SHY vs Finding Winnie

Mini Mighty Smackdown- Jasman-Pritpal-Sugam-Mannat

Summary-SHY by Deborah Freedman
The characters in this book are Florence the yellow bird and a giraffe named Shy.A giraffe named Shy loved reading books about birds.But, he had never seen a bird in front of his eyes.Then one day a bird named Florence, appeared in front of The giraffe.He wanted to follow the bird but he had never left home because of danger.He followed the bird and then at night he lost track of the bird.But Shy got home.The next day he was reading a book about birds and he heard the bird and Florence was there.They became best friends.

Finding Winnie - Lindsay Mattick 

This is a story about a true bear named Winnie.A man named Harry brought him from a man for $20 at White River.He took him to the 
army with him.They became best friends.Harry had a war that Winnie could not go to world war 1 so Harry dropped him to the zoo.  Harry had  a boy his boy had a girl when she grew she had a girl named Lindsay Mattick who wrote the book.


Smackdown
 Opinion

Finding Winnie won the Smackdown 4/4.We chose finding Winnie because we loved the book because it was a true story.The illustrations were inspired by the real pictures of the Bear. We also loved how much Harry loved and cared for Winnie.We liked how so many people loved that they made  books with a character named Winnie the Pooh. It was our favourite story book even though we love SHY.